I’ve been slowly coming around to an idea that’s so simple, and yet so hard to face — it’s part of what Havi would call my “Stuff,” no doubt about it.
I am overweight and out of shape — yeah, big shock, someone on the internet who isn’t in perfect health. And every day I think about how I’d like to feel better, have more energy, get all those supposed benefits of being healthy. And all you have to do to get there is eat well and exercise, right?
Except here’s the conundrum:
I have never, ever associated exercise with feeling good.
Everyone who talks about exercising says it’ll give you more energy, that exercise is the key to feeling good, that you can just find that one magic thing you love to do and it’ll make you thin and svelte and awesome.
But I’m not actually any good at any of those things. I’m awkward. I have bad knees. I was always picked last in gym class, and it’s the only class I was ever in danger of failing.
Exercise is a bad thing to me. It’s humiliation and incompetence and that horrible sick feeling you get when you’re forced to try to do things your body isn’t ready for because some authority figure thinks it should be. It’s being the worst at something, and being forced to do it over and over again anyway.
This is not something that makes me think I will feel good and have more energy. In fact, it makes me feel tired and a little sick just contemplating it.
How can I solve this conundrum? I don’t know. I have been walking a lot more, but in that way where nothing is ever good enough, that’s not really helping much anymore. It’s been a couple of years since I made the change, and so I’ve long past reached that plateau where I’m supposed to “up the intensity” or some shit. But my errands? Not that intense.
I could try to relate this to work — how still you have to do the parts that aren’t your best thing in order to do the bits you’re really good at, how a lot of businesses hit a plateau where you have to work a whole bunch more if you want to keep seeing growth, and all that. And it’s all true.
But I never had a gym teacher yell at me for not doing my marketing.
RSS feed for comments on this post.
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.
Comment by Ad Baculum — June 19, 2009 @ 2:45 pm
Everyone who talks about exercising says it'll give you more energy, that exercise is the key to feeling good, that you can just find that one magic thing you love to do and it'll make you thin and svelte and awesome.
I actually don't think it will make me thin and svelte (and I am already awesome, so that is not a concern :), but I did make the sad realization this week that I need exercise to not be depressed. And not just the standard 'oh, you can just walk for a half hour a few times a week' kind of thing. (Which I do as part of my life anyway–the walking everywhere, the bike commuting, etc. It has never helped with anything.) No, apparently I require 1-2 hrs a day, 6-7 days a week of fairly rigorous movement. And that doesn't even get me to the "feeling good" stage; that gets me to slightly positive neutral.
I'm not sure how I feel about that revelation…
Anyway, there's always pole dancing. It requires money and my mom tells me there's a lot of being bad at it until you're suddenly not, but it sounds like the type of exercise that maybe you can frame to yourself as not-exercise?
Comment by Amy — June 19, 2009 @ 2:54 pm
@Ad I have trouble with the idea that I should work more so I can have money to pay someone to do something I never wanted to do in the first place. This is, I fear, part of the conundrum.
Never having gotten exercise on a regular basis (because of the hate, you see), I have no idea what it would do for my mood — but I'd hate to give up 2 hours a day to it unless it was something really awesome. 🙁
Comment by Leah — June 29, 2009 @ 2:02 pm
I also hated gym class. Dreaded it. But I do exercise now. I've found that it's essential for my mental health, so I need to find ways to make it part of my life.
For me, fun and some kind of challenge help keep me going. Also gentleness is important (beating myself up or overdoing never works.) I can't do it to lose weight or I'll avoid it or drive myself bonkers. But if I do it to feel good, it helps.
I started out with walking and still do a good deal of that. Listening to books on tape helps make that more enjoyable for me.
Another approach to take is grooving to your favorite music. Putting on your favorite tunes and dancing around for 15 minutes a day is a great way to get in some painless exercise and have some good silly fun too. And it's free. 🙂
In my experience, the best place to start when in an exercise conundrum is small and fun. Hope that helps!
Comment by Amy — June 29, 2009 @ 2:42 pm
@Leah Yeah, it's hard for me to find the fun in exercise, or any kind of "feel good" result.
I'm taking a different approach right now, and trying out Shiva Nata — doing it for my brain sounds like about my speed. I'm excited, my DVD just showed up!
Comment by intrepidgirl — June 29, 2009 @ 10:47 pm
Hi Amy,
You posted on Havi's blog earlier today (or yesterday, perhaps?) – that's how I found you. i came over to your blog and as I read your post about exercise I felt compelled to comment because one year ago I too was a woman with bad knees, only forty pounds heavier than I am now.
I had been "heavy" for as long as I can remember and until last year I let it stop me from really living. I kept thinking if I just lost weight I would travel more or get the job of my dreams, or…or..or..
I don't know what really changed last year except that i was done making excuses so I did two things: I joined Jenny Craig (honestly I NEVER thought I'd be someone who did that) and I joined a lovely yoga studio. Because I have bad knees, I wanted something that was low-to-no impact.
Turns out yoga plus JC worked wonders for me.
Part of the reason yoga worked so well is the incredible and loving community at my studio. So if you can find a community like that where you live, I encourage you to embrace it. Be REALLY selective about yoga studios. Shop around. I had a yoga teacher once call out to me in class as "NEW GIRL!". I never went back. In fact, I stayed away from yoga for a few years because of it. I wish someone had told me that experience was not the norm and to look around for a studio that suited me better. I want to offer that to you now, in case it's helpful. Also, I'm not an "exercise' person. I get bored (OMG do I get bored!) at the gym. But learning yoga was learning a new skill, pushing my limits, finding things I could and couldn't do, and it was amazingly liberating.
The other thing that has worked miracles for my knees is acupuncture. I know a lot of people get queasy at the idea of needles, but I cannot swear enough how life changing acupuncture has been for me and my knees. Where they used to balloon up for days, now they get a little pissy but don't get nearly as inflamed or for as long as they used to. Plus my relationship with my acupuncturist has been better than any therapy.
I offer all of this here to you. if I can provide help, encouragement or guidance to you I would be so happy to do so. No matter what, I'll be over here, cheering you on your journey.
All the best,
intrepidgirl
Comment by Amy — June 30, 2009 @ 10:48 am
@Intrepidgirl Wow, what a great story! Thank you for coming over here to share it with me.
To be honest I'm not sure how much of your story is as like mine as the surface seems — I haven't always been bigger, so I have that goal of getting back to what I know I can be, for instance. Also, I can't join any of the provided-meal plans due to food allergies. I couldn't eat half the food anyway. 😉
I'm really excited to start Shiva Nata today (in a little while!), and I've been thinking of finding a yoga studio nearby, but as I told Ad, I'm not sure I'm all that down with the idea of working harder to make more money so I can do something I don't really want to do in the first place. It's part of my Stuff, but it's also a train of logic I find hard to refute!
We'll see if Shiva Nata can help break up that pattern along with some others.
Comment by katanaville — July 12, 2009 @ 4:09 pm
oh, ME TOO.
for me it was gym clothes. i always had awful awful gym clothes i hated wearing and so I wouldn't. i was a good kid, but i skipped gym class frequently.
thank you!
i gravitate towards sports that involve being covered head to tow (snowboarding, surfing) and refuse to do anything that requires shorts and a t-shirt, or exertion. Believe it or not, snowboarding is not exertion, it's just bruises. Heh.
Comment by Amy — July 12, 2009 @ 7:29 pm
@katanaville Gah, let's not think about gym clothes. To this day I don't wear shorts!
Comment by thesecretlifeofwormhill — September 14, 2009 @ 2:03 am
I agree with @katanaville that snowboarding is mostly bruises! LOTS of bruises. heh.
I went to a school where sports were a major focus and winning was the primary focus of that. Needless to say I left with a distinct aversion to competition and being forced to do any sport. However, I do enjoy being active and that's where my conundrum began.
Like you I get very bored in the gym. I also hate routine, so a class every Thurdsay or Saturday does not suit me at all. What has helped is finding something that does not feel like exercise to me. I now climb, mountain bike, hike and run because these things are fun and then the secondary benefit is that I get fit and burn some calories.
First though, I had to make it okay not to exercise or do anything active and I made peace with my body through hundreds of hours of journaling. After that I could begin to explore finding a hobby that was fun and active and I'm very glad I have. But I have to stress, it is never about weight loss or "exercise" and it is only ever about having fun. That's the only way I can do it.
Comment by Amy — September 14, 2009 @ 12:53 pm
@thesecretofwormhill That's the real problem – I don't think any of those things sound fun. There are a very few things that involve exercise that seem like fun to me!
I guess I'll just have to pull out DDR more often. 😉